I’m So Surprised

Back in May, 2007, Pres. Bush said that the United States would leave Iraq if Iraq’s government asked us to:

… We are there at the invitation of the Iraqi government. This is a sovereign nation. Twelve million people went to the polls to approve a constitution. It’s their government’s choice. If they were to say, leave, we would leave.
I would hope that they would recognize that the results would be catastrophic. This is a sovereign nation, Martha. We are there at their request. And hopefully the Iraqi government would be wise enough to recognize that without coalition troops, the U.S. troops, that they would endanger their very existence. And it’s why we work very closely with them, to make sure that the realities are such that they wouldn’t make that request — but if they were to make the request, we wouldn’t be there.

The Associated Press reports today that al-Maliki objects to Petraeus’s recommendation, and Pres. Bush’s acceptance of same, that U.S. troop withdrawals be halted.

The renewed violence coincided with the Congressional testimony of the Bush administration’s top two officials in Iraq — Gen. David Petraeus and Ambassador Ryan Crocker. Petraeus recommended a pause in drawing down U.S. troops in Iraq while the security situation remains unstable and President Bush is expected to follow his recommendation.

But Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki disagreed with Petraeus’ proposal to delay further U.S. troop withdrawals, citing the growing capabilities of Iraq’s own security forces.

Petraeus wants the U.S. to complete by the end of July the withdrawal of the 20,000 troops that were sent to Iraq last year, leaving about 140,000 in the country. Beyond that, the general proposed a 45-day evaluation period to be followed by an indefinite period of assessment before any further pullouts.

Al-Maliki, however, has said he disagrees with that decision.

The prime minister told Bush during a 20-minute telephone conversation on Wednesday that Iraqi security forces are capable of carrying out their duties and U.S. troops should be pulled out as the situation permits, according to a senior government adviser who sat in on the phone conversation. He spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to disclose the confidential details.

Ben at Think Progress (source of the above links):

Bush has consistently expressed confidence in Maliki’s leadership and judgement saying he had seen “the strength of his character,” that he is a “strong leader,” and a “good guy” with “deep determination.”

If Bush has so much confidence in Maliki’s character and leadership abilities, then perhaps he should take his advice.

3 Responses to “I’m So Surprised”

  1. Chief says:

    I’d hate to have someone think that I was shamelessly blogwhoring but this is part of a larger post I put up yesterday at Liberty Street.

    “Winning for George W. Bush and his handlers is getting cheap access to Iraqi oil. Iraq has the largest reserves of oil in the mid-East. And it is sweet crude (low sulpher). Saudi has a lot of oil but is sour, high Sulpher. The Iraqi government has signed long term contracts with some major international oil companies at terms that are not real favorable to the Iraqi people.”

    “Once the United States troops leave, you can safely bet that the government that is installed after the civil war will not be the one that signed the contracts and the oil companies may be nationalized. No greater fear has an oilman than a government taking over their company, equipment and profits. This is really what Bush fears.”

    The full post is here: http://libertystreet.wordpress.com/2008/04/10/winning/

  2. Blogwhoring is perfectly welcome chief. Perfectly welcome

  3. Kirkrrt says:


    The Iraqi government hasn’t signed any deals yet. You need to check your facts.

    That doesn’t mean your first statement is wrong. Your definition of winning seems right on the mark.

    Your second paragraph is dead on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Connect with Facebook